xref: /libCEED/doc/sphinx/source/releasenotes.md (revision 6e15d496119073f7bc35f61df7ac100e9376600e)
1bcb2dfaeSJed Brown# Changes/Release Notes
2bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
3bcb2dfaeSJed BrownOn this page we provide a summary of the main API changes, new features and examples
4bcb2dfaeSJed Brownfor each release of libCEED.
5bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
6bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(main)=
7bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
8bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## Current `main` branch
9bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
107e7773b5SJeremy L Thompson### Interface changes
117e7773b5SJeremy L Thompson
12*6e15d496SJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedQFunctionSetUserFlopsEstimate` and {c:func}`CeedOperatorGetFlopsEstimate` to facilitate estimating FLOPs in operator application.
13*6e15d496SJeremy L Thompson
14667e613fSJeremy L Thompson(v0-10)=
15667e613fSJeremy L Thompson
163ed90579SJeremy L Thompson## v0.10 (Mar 21, 2022)
17667e613fSJeremy L Thompson
18667e613fSJeremy L Thompson### Interface changes
19667e613fSJeremy L Thompson
207e7773b5SJeremy L Thompson- Update {c:func}`CeedQFunctionGetFields` and {c:func}`CeedOperatorGetFields` to include number of fields.
21ce4822f6SJeremy L Thompson- Promote to the public API: QFunction and Operator field objects, `CeedQFunctionField` and `CeedOperatorField`, and associated getters, {c:func}`CeedQFunctionGetFields`; {c:func}`CeedQFunctionFieldGetName`; {c:func}`CeedQFunctionFieldGetSize`; {c:func}`CeedQFunctionFieldGetEvalMode`; {c:func}`CeedOperatorGetFields`; {c:func}`CeedOperatorFieldGetElemRestriction`; {c:func}`CeedOperatorFieldGetBasis`; and {c:func}`CeedOperatorFieldGetVector`.
22f04ea552SJeremy L Thompson- Clarify and document conditions where `CeedQFunction` and `CeedOperator` become immutable and no further fields or suboperators can be added.
2370a7ffb3SJeremy L Thompson- Add {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssembleQFunctionBuildOrUpdate` to reduce object creation overhead in assembly of CeedOperator preconditioning ingredients.
244db537f9SJeremy L Thompson- Promote {c:func}`CeedOperatorCheckReady`to the public API to facilitate interactive interfaces.
25dcc1e3ecSJeremy L Thompson- Warning added when compiling OCCA backend to alert users that this backend is experimental.
269a1d3511SJeremy L Thompson- `ceed-backend.h`, `ceed-hash.h`, and `ceed-khash.h` removed. Users should use `ceed/backend.h`, `ceed/hash.h`, and `ceed/khash.h`.
2743e1b16fSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedQFunctionGetKernelName`; refactored {c:func}`CeedQFunctionGetSourcePath` to exclude function kernel name.
289c774eddSJeremy L Thompson- Clarify documentation for {c:func}`CeedVectorTakeArray`; this function will error if {c:func}`CeedVectorSetArray` with `copy_mode == CEED_USE_POINTER` was not previously called for the corresponding `CeedMemType`.
299c774eddSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedVectorGetArrayWrite` that allows access to uninitalized arrays; require initalized data for {c:func}`CeedVectorGetArray`.
30c38440baSJed Brown- Added {c:func}`CeedQFunctionContextRegisterDouble` and {c:func}`CeedQFunctionContextRegisterInt32` with {c:func}`CeedQFunctionContextSetDouble` and {c:func}`CeedQFunctionContextSetInt32` to facilitate easy updating of {c:struct}`CeedQFunctionContext` data by user defined field names.
31cdf32b93SJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedQFunctionContextGetFieldDescriptions` to retreive user defined descriptions of fields that are registered with `CeedQFunctionContextRegister*`.
327a06ec9fSJeremy L Thompson- Renamed `CeedElemTopology` entries for clearer namespacing between libCEED enums.
33f4f98f9dSJeremy L Thompson- Added type `CeedSize` equivalent to `ptrdiff_t` for array sizes in {c:func}`CeedVectorCreate`, {c:func}`CeedVectorGetLength`, `CeedElemRestrictionCreate*`, {c:func}`CeedElemRestrictionGetLVectorSize`, and {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssembleSymbolic`. This is a breaking change.
348b919e6bSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedOperatorSetQFunctionUpdated` to facilitate QFunction data re-use between operators sharing the same quadrature space, such as in a multigrid hierarchy.
35c9366a6bSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedOperatorGetActiveVectorLengths` to get shape of CeedOperator.
367e7773b5SJeremy L Thompson
37f479eb23SJeremy L Thompson### New features
38f479eb23SJeremy L Thompson
39f479eb23SJeremy L Thompson- `CeedScalar` can now be set as `float` or `double` at compile time.
4030601ac0SJeremy L Thompson- Added JiT utilities in `ceed/jit-tools.h` to reduce duplicated code in GPU backends.
41fb3c7d02SJeremy L Thompson- Added support for JiT of QFunctions with `#include "relative/path/local-file.h"` statements for additional local files. Note that files included with `""` are searched relative to the current file first, then by compiler paths (as with `<>` includes). To use this feature, one should adhere to relative paths only, not compiler flags like `-I`, which the JiT will not be aware of.
4223dfbf5bSJeremy L Thompson- Remove need to guard library headers in QFunction source for code generation backends.
433f21f6b1SJeremy L Thompson- `CeedDebugEnv()` macro created to provide debugging outputs when Ceed context is not present.
44f7e22acaSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedStringAllocCopy` to reduce repeated code for copying strings internally.
453451974fSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedPathConcatenate` to facilitate loading kernel source files with a path relative to the current file.
467a06ec9fSJeremy L Thompson- Added support for non-tensor H(div) elements, to include CPU backend implementations and {c:func}`CeedBasisCreateHdiv` convenience constructor.
47d34e270fSJeremy L Thompson- Added {c:func}`CeedQFunctionSetContextWritable` and read-only access to `CeedQFunctionContext` data as an optional feature to improve GPU performance. By default, calling the `CeedQFunctionUser` during {c:func}`CeedQFunctionApply` is assumed to write into the `CeedQFunctionContext` data, consistent with the previous behavior. Note that if a user asserts that their `CeedQFunctionUser` does not write into the `CeedQFunctionContext` data, they are responsible for the validity of this assertion.
4859ad764aSnbeams- Added support for element matrix assembly in GPU backends.
49f479eb23SJeremy L Thompson
50bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Maintainability
51bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
52bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Refactored preconditioner support internally to facilitate future development and improve GPU completeness/test coverage.
53db52d626SJeremy L Thompson- `Include-what-you-use` makefile target added as `make iwyu`.
54bf4cb664SJeremy L Thompson- Create backend constant `CEED_FIELD_MAX` to reduce magic numbers in codebase.
553451974fSJeremy L Thompson- Put GPU JiTed kernel source code into separate files.
56f9996dfdSJeremy L Thompson- Dropped legacy version support in PETSc based examples to better utilize PETSc DMPlex and Mat updates to support libCEED; current minimum PETSc version for the examples is v3.17.
57bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
58bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-9)=
59bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
60bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.9 (Jul 6, 2021)
61bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
62bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Interface changes
63bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
64bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Minor modification in error handling macro to silence pedantic warnings when compiling with Clang, but no functional impact.
65bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
66bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### New features
67bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
68bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Add {c:func}`CeedVectorAXPY` and {c:func}`CeedVectorPointwiseMult` as a convenience for stand-alone testing and internal use.
69bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Add `CEED_QFUNCTION_HELPER` macro to properly annotate QFunction helper functions for code generation backends.
70bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Add `CeedPragmaOptimizeOff` macro for code that is sensitive to floating point errors from fast math optimizations.
71bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Rust support: split `libceed-sys` crate out of `libceed` and [publish both on crates.io](https://crates.io/crates/libceed).
72bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
73bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Performance improvements
74bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
75bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Examples
76bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
77bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Solid mechanics mini-app updated to explore the performance impacts of various formulations in the initial and current configurations.
78bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Fluid mechanics example adds GPU support and improves modularity.
79bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
80bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Deprecated backends
81bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
82bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- The `/cpu/self/tmpl` and `/cpu/self/tmpl/sub` backends have been removed. These backends were intially added to test the backend inheritance mechanism, but this mechanism is now widely used and tested in multiple backends.
83bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
84bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-8)=
85bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
86bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.8 (Mar 31, 2021)
87bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
88bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Interface changes
89bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
90bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Error handling improved to include enumerated error codes for C interface return values.
91bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Installed headers that will follow semantic versioning were moved to {code}`include/ceed` directory. These headers have been renamed from {code}`ceed-*.h` to {code}`ceed/*.h`. Placeholder headers with the old naming schema are currently provided, but these headers will be removed in the libCEED v0.9 release.
92bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
93bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### New features
94bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
95bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Julia and Rust interfaces added, providing a nearly 1-1 correspondence with the C interface, plus some convenience features.
96bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Static libraries can be built with `make STATIC=1` and the pkg-config file is installed accordingly.
97bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Add {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssembleSymbolic` and {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssemble` to support full assembly of libCEED operators.
98bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
99bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Performance improvements
100bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
101bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- New HIP MAGMA backends for hipMAGMA library users: `/gpu/hip/magma` and `/gpu/hip/magma/det`.
102bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- New HIP backends for improved tensor basis performance: `/gpu/hip/shared` and `/gpu/hip/gen`.
103bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
104bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Examples
105bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
106bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-elasticity` example updated with traction boundary conditions and improved Dirichlet boundary conditions.
107bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-elasticity` example updated with Neo-Hookean hyperelasticity in current configuration as well as improved Neo-Hookean hyperelasticity exploring storage vs computation tradeoffs.
108bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-navier-stokes` example updated with isentropic traveling vortex test case, an analytical solution to the Euler equations that is useful for testing boundary conditions, discretization stability, and order of accuracy.
109bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-navier-stokes` example updated with support for performing convergence study and plotting order of convergence by polynomial degree.
110bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
111bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-7)=
112bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
113bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.7 (Sep 29, 2020)
114bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
115bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Interface changes
116bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
117bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Replace limited {code}`CeedInterlaceMode` with more flexible component stride {code}`compstride` in {code}`CeedElemRestriction` constructors.
118bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  As a result, the {code}`indices` parameter has been replaced with {code}`offsets` and the {code}`nnodes` parameter has been replaced with {code}`lsize`.
119bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  These changes improve support for mixed finite element methods.
120bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Replace various uses of {code}`Ceed*Get*Status` with {code}`Ceed*Is*` in the backend API to match common nomenclature.
121bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Replace {code}`CeedOperatorAssembleLinearDiagonal` with {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssembleDiagonal` for clarity.
122bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Linear Operators can be assembled as point-block diagonal matrices with {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssemblePointBlockDiagonal`, provided in row-major form in a {code}`ncomp` by {code}`ncomp` block per node.
123bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Diagonal assemble interface changed to accept a {ref}`CeedVector` instead of a pointer to a {ref}`CeedVector` to reduce memory movement when interfacing with calling code.
124bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Added {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssembleAddDiagonal` and {c:func}`CeedOperatorLinearAssembleAddPointBlockDiagonal` for improved future integration with codes such as MFEM that compose the action of {ref}`CeedOperator`s external to libCEED.
125bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Added {c:func}`CeedVectorTakeAray` to sync and remove libCEED read/write access to an allocated array and pass ownership of the array to the caller.
126bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  This function is recommended over {c:func}`CeedVectorSyncArray` when the {code}`CeedVector` has an array owned by the caller that was set by {c:func}`CeedVectorSetArray`.
127bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Added {code}`CeedQFunctionContext` object to manage user QFunction context data and reduce copies between device and host memory.
128bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Added {c:func}`CeedOperatorMultigridLevelCreate`, {c:func}`CeedOperatorMultigridLevelCreateTensorH1`, and {c:func}`CeedOperatorMultigridLevelCreateH1` to facilitate creation of multigrid prolongation, restriction, and coarse grid operators using a common quadrature space.
129bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
130bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### New features
131bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
132bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- New HIP backend: `/gpu/hip/ref`.
133bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- CeedQFunction support for user `CUfunction`s in some backends
134bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
135bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Performance improvements
136bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
137bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- OCCA backend rebuilt to facilitate future performance enhancements.
138bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Petsc BPs suite improved to reduce noise due to multiple calls to {code}`mpiexec`.
139bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
140bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Examples
141bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
142bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-elasticity` example updated with strain energy computation and more flexible boundary conditions.
143bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
144bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Deprecated backends
145bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
146bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- The `/gpu/cuda/reg` backend has been removed, with its core features moved into `/gpu/cuda/ref` and `/gpu/cuda/shared`.
147bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
148bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-6)=
149bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
150bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.6 (Mar 29, 2020)
151bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
152bcb2dfaeSJed BrownlibCEED v0.6 contains numerous new features and examples, as well as expanded
15313964f07SJed Browndocumentation in [this new website](https://libceed.org).
154bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
155bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### New features
156bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
157bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- New Python interface using [CFFI](https://cffi.readthedocs.io/) provides a nearly
158bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  1-1 correspondence with the C interface, plus some convenience features.  For instance,
159bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  data stored in the {cpp:type}`CeedVector` structure are available without copy as
160bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {py:class}`numpy.ndarray`.  Short tutorials are provided in
161bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  [Binder](https://mybinder.org/v2/gh/CEED/libCEED/main?urlpath=lab/tree/examples/tutorials/).
162bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Linear QFunctions can be assembled as block-diagonal matrices (per quadrature point,
163bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedOperatorAssembleLinearQFunction`) or to evaluate the diagonal
164bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  ({c:func}`CeedOperatorAssembleLinearDiagonal`).  These operations are useful for
165bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  preconditioning ingredients and are used in the libCEED's multigrid examples.
166bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- The inverse of separable operators can be obtained using
167bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedOperatorCreateFDMElementInverse` and applied with
168bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedOperatorApply`.  This is a useful preconditioning ingredient,
169bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  especially for Laplacians and related operators.
170bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- New functions: {c:func}`CeedVectorNorm`, {c:func}`CeedOperatorApplyAdd`,
171bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedQFunctionView`, {c:func}`CeedOperatorView`.
172bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Make public accessors for various attributes to facilitate writing composable code.
173bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- New backend: `/cpu/self/memcheck/serial`.
174bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- QFunctions using variable-length array (VLA) pointer constructs can be used with CUDA
175bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  backends.  (Single source is coming soon for OCCA backends.)
176bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Fix some missing edge cases in CUDA backend.
177bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
178bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Performance Improvements
179bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
180bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- MAGMA backend performance optimization and non-tensor bases.
181bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- No-copy optimization in {c:func}`CeedOperatorApply`.
182bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
183bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Interface changes
184bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
185bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Replace {code}`CeedElemRestrictionCreateIdentity` and
186bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {code}`CeedElemRestrictionCreateBlocked` with more flexible
187bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedElemRestrictionCreateStrided` and
188bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedElemRestrictionCreateBlockedStrided`.
189bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Add arguments to {c:func}`CeedQFunctionCreateIdentity`.
190bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Replace ambiguous uses of {cpp:enum}`CeedTransposeMode` for L-vector identification
191bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  with {cpp:enum}`CeedInterlaceMode`.  This is now an attribute of the
192bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {cpp:type}`CeedElemRestriction` (see {c:func}`CeedElemRestrictionCreate`) and no
193bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  longer passed as `lmode` arguments to {c:func}`CeedOperatorSetField` and
194bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  {c:func}`CeedElemRestrictionApply`.
195bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
196bcb2dfaeSJed Brown### Examples
197bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
198bcb2dfaeSJed BrownlibCEED-0.6 contains greatly expanded examples with {ref}`new documentation <Examples>`.
199bcb2dfaeSJed BrownNotable additions include:
200bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
201bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- Standalone {ref}`ex2-surface` ({file}`examples/ceed/ex2-surface`): compute the area of
202bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  a domain in 1, 2, and 3 dimensions by applying a Laplacian.
203bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
204bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- PETSc {ref}`example-petsc-area` ({file}`examples/petsc/area.c`): computes surface area
205bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  of domains (like the cube and sphere) by direct integration on a surface mesh;
206bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  demonstrates geometric dimension different from topological dimension.
207bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
208bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- PETSc {ref}`example-petsc-bps`:
209bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
210bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  - {file}`examples/petsc/bpsraw.c` (formerly `bps.c`): transparent CUDA support.
211bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  - {file}`examples/petsc/bps.c` (formerly `bpsdmplex.c`): performance improvements
212bcb2dfaeSJed Brown    and transparent CUDA support.
213bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  - {ref}`example-petsc-bps-sphere` ({file}`examples/petsc/bpssphere.c`):
214bcb2dfaeSJed Brown    generalizations of all CEED BPs to the surface of the sphere; demonstrates geometric
215bcb2dfaeSJed Brown    dimension different from topological dimension.
216bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
217bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-multigrid` ({file}`examples/petsc/multigrid.c`): new p-multigrid
218bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  solver with algebraic multigrid coarse solve.
219bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
220bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-navier-stokes` ({file}`examples/fluids/navierstokes.c`; formerly
221bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  `examples/navier-stokes`): unstructured grid support (using PETSc's `DMPlex`),
222bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  implicit time integration, SU/SUPG stabilization, free-slip boundary conditions, and
223bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  quasi-2D computational domain support.
224bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
225bcb2dfaeSJed Brown- {ref}`example-petsc-elasticity` ({file}`examples/solids/elasticity.c`): new solver for
226bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  linear elasticity, small-strain hyperelasticity, and globalized finite-strain
227bcb2dfaeSJed Brown  hyperelasticity using p-multigrid with algebraic multigrid coarse solve.
228bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
229bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-5)=
230bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
231bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.5 (Sep 18, 2019)
232bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
233bcb2dfaeSJed BrownFor this release, several improvements were made. Two new CUDA backends were added to
234bcb2dfaeSJed Brownthe family of backends, of which, the new `cuda-gen` backend achieves state-of-the-art
235bcb2dfaeSJed Brownperformance using single-source {ref}`CeedQFunction`. From this release, users
236bcb2dfaeSJed Browncan define Q-Functions in a single source code independently of the targeted backend
237bcb2dfaeSJed Brownwith the aid of a new macro `CEED QFUNCTION` to support JIT (Just-In-Time) and CPU
238bcb2dfaeSJed Browncompilation of the user provided {ref}`CeedQFunction` code. To allow a unified
239bcb2dfaeSJed Browndeclaration, the {ref}`CeedQFunction` API has undergone a slight change:
240bcb2dfaeSJed Brownthe `QFunctionField` parameter `ncomp` has been changed to `size`. This change
241bcb2dfaeSJed Brownrequires setting the previous value of `ncomp` to `ncomp*dim` when adding a
242bcb2dfaeSJed Brown`QFunctionField` with eval mode `CEED EVAL GRAD`.
243bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
244bcb2dfaeSJed BrownAdditionally, new CPU backends
245bcb2dfaeSJed Brownwere included in this release, such as the `/cpu/self/opt/*` backends (which are
246bcb2dfaeSJed Brownwritten in pure C and use partial **E-vectors** to improve performance) and the
247bcb2dfaeSJed Brown`/cpu/self/ref/memcheck` backend (which relies upon the
248bcb2dfaeSJed Brown[Valgrind](http://valgrind.org/) Memcheck tool to help verify that user
249bcb2dfaeSJed Brown{ref}`CeedQFunction` have no undefined values).
250bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThis release also included various performance improvements, bug fixes, new examples,
251bcb2dfaeSJed Brownand improved tests. Among these improvements, vectorized instructions for
252bcb2dfaeSJed Brown{ref}`CeedQFunction` code compiled for CPU were enhanced by using `CeedPragmaSIMD`
253bcb2dfaeSJed Browninstead of `CeedPragmaOMP`, implementation of a {ref}`CeedQFunction` gallery and
254bcb2dfaeSJed Brownidentity Q-Functions were introduced, and the PETSc benchmark problems were expanded
255bcb2dfaeSJed Brownto include unstructured meshes handling were. For this expansion, the prior version of
256bcb2dfaeSJed Brownthe PETSc BPs, which only included data associated with structured geometries, were
257bcb2dfaeSJed Brownrenamed `bpsraw`, and the new version of the BPs, which can handle data associated
258bcb2dfaeSJed Brownwith any unstructured geometry, were called `bps`. Additionally, other benchmark
259bcb2dfaeSJed Brownproblems, namely BP2 and BP4 (the vector-valued versions of BP1 and BP3, respectively),
260bcb2dfaeSJed Brownand BP5 and BP6 (the collocated versions---for which the quadrature points are the same
261bcb2dfaeSJed Brownas the Gauss Lobatto nodes---of BP3 and BP4 respectively) were added to the PETSc
262bcb2dfaeSJed Brownexamples. Furthermoew, another standalone libCEED example, called `ex2`, which
263bcb2dfaeSJed Browncomputes the surface area of a given mesh was added to this release.
264bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
265bcb2dfaeSJed BrownBackends available in this release:
266bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
26768e843eeSJed Brown| CEED resource (`-ceed`)  | Backend                                             |
26868e843eeSJed Brown|--------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------|
26968e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/ref/serial`   | Serial reference implementation                     |
27068e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/ref/blocked`  | Blocked reference implementation                    |
27168e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/ref/memcheck` | Memcheck backend, undefined value checks            |
27268e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/opt/serial`   | Serial optimized C implementation                   |
27368e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/opt/blocked`  | Blocked optimized C implementation                  |
27468e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/avx/serial`   | Serial AVX implementation                           |
27568e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/avx/blocked`  | Blocked AVX implementation                          |
27668e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/xsmm/serial`  | Serial LIBXSMM implementation                       |
27768e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/xsmm/blocked` | Blocked LIBXSMM implementation                      |
27868e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/occa`              | Serial OCCA kernels                                 |
27968e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/occa`              | CUDA OCCA kernels                                   |
28068e843eeSJed Brown| `/omp/occa`              | OpenMP OCCA kernels                                 |
28168e843eeSJed Brown| `/ocl/occa`              | OpenCL OCCA kernels                                 |
28268e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/cuda/ref`          | Reference pure CUDA kernels                         |
28368e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/cuda/reg`          | Pure CUDA kernels using one thread per element      |
28468e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/cuda/shared`       | Optimized pure CUDA kernels using shared memory     |
28568e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/cuda/gen`          | Optimized pure CUDA kernels using code generation   |
28668e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/magma`             | CUDA MAGMA kernels                                  |
287bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
288bcb2dfaeSJed BrownExamples available in this release:
289bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
29068e843eeSJed Brown:::{list-table}
29168e843eeSJed Brown:header-rows: 1
29268e843eeSJed Brown:widths: auto
29368e843eeSJed Brown* - User code
29468e843eeSJed Brown  - Example
29568e843eeSJed Brown* - `ceed`
29668e843eeSJed Brown  - * ex1 (volume)
29768e843eeSJed Brown    * ex2 (surface)
29868e843eeSJed Brown* - `mfem`
29968e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
30068e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
30168e843eeSJed Brown* - `petsc`
30268e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
30368e843eeSJed Brown    * BP2 (vector mass operator)
30468e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
30568e843eeSJed Brown    * BP4 (vector Laplace operator)
30668e843eeSJed Brown    * BP5 (collocated scalar Laplace operator)
30768e843eeSJed Brown    * BP6 (collocated vector Laplace operator)
30868e843eeSJed Brown    * Navier-Stokes
30968e843eeSJed Brown* - `nek5000`
31068e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
31168e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
31268e843eeSJed Brown:::
313bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
314bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-4)=
315bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
316bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.4 (Apr 1, 2019)
317bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
318bcb2dfaeSJed BrownlibCEED v0.4 was made again publicly available in the second full CEED software
319bcb2dfaeSJed Browndistribution, release CEED 2.0. This release contained notable features, such as
320bcb2dfaeSJed Brownfour new CPU backends, two new GPU backends, CPU backend optimizations, initial
321bcb2dfaeSJed Brownsupport for operator composition, performance benchmarking, and a Navier-Stokes demo.
322bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThe new CPU backends in this release came in two families. The `/cpu/self/*/serial`
323bcb2dfaeSJed Brownbackends process one element at a time and are intended for meshes with a smaller number
324bcb2dfaeSJed Brownof high order elements. The `/cpu/self/*/blocked` backends process blocked batches of
325bcb2dfaeSJed Browneight interlaced elements and are intended for meshes with higher numbers of elements.
326bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThe `/cpu/self/avx/*` backends rely upon AVX instructions to provide vectorized CPU
327bcb2dfaeSJed Brownperformance. The `/cpu/self/xsmm/*` backends rely upon the
328bcb2dfaeSJed Brown[LIBXSMM](http://github.com/hfp/libxsmm) package to provide vectorized CPU
329bcb2dfaeSJed Brownperformance. The `/gpu/cuda/*` backends provide GPU performance strictly using CUDA.
330bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThe `/gpu/cuda/ref` backend is a reference CUDA backend, providing reasonable
331bcb2dfaeSJed Brownperformance for most problem configurations. The `/gpu/cuda/reg` backend uses a simple
332bcb2dfaeSJed Brownparallelization approach, where each thread treats a finite element. Using just in time
333bcb2dfaeSJed Browncompilation, provided by nvrtc (NVidia Runtime Compiler), and runtime parameters, this
334bcb2dfaeSJed Brownbackend unroll loops and map memory address to registers. The `/gpu/cuda/reg` backend
335bcb2dfaeSJed Brownachieve good peak performance for 1D, 2D, and low order 3D problems, but performance
336bcb2dfaeSJed Browndeteriorates very quickly when threads run out of registers.
337bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
338bcb2dfaeSJed BrownA new explicit time-stepping Navier-Stokes solver was added to the family of libCEED
339bcb2dfaeSJed Brownexamples in the `examples/petsc` directory (see {ref}`example-petsc-navier-stokes`).
340bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThis example solves the time-dependent Navier-Stokes equations of compressible gas
341bcb2dfaeSJed Browndynamics in a static Eulerian three-dimensional frame, using structured high-order
342bcb2dfaeSJed Brownfinite/spectral element spatial discretizations and explicit high-order time-stepping
343bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(available in PETSc). Moreover, the Navier-Stokes example was developed using PETSc,
344bcb2dfaeSJed Brownso that the pointwise physics (defined at quadrature points) is separated from the
345bcb2dfaeSJed Brownparallelization and meshing concerns.
346bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
347bcb2dfaeSJed BrownBackends available in this release:
348bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
34968e843eeSJed Brown| CEED resource (`-ceed`)  | Backend                                             |
35068e843eeSJed Brown|--------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------|
35168e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/ref/serial`   | Serial reference implementation                     |
35268e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/ref/blocked`  | Blocked reference implementation                    |
35368e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/tmpl`         | Backend template, defaults to `/cpu/self/blocked`   |
35468e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/avx/serial`   | Serial AVX implementation                           |
35568e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/avx/blocked`  | Blocked AVX implementation                          |
35668e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/xsmm/serial`  | Serial LIBXSMM implementation                       |
35768e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/xsmm/blocked` | Blocked LIBXSMM implementation                      |
35868e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/occa`              | Serial OCCA kernels                                 |
35968e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/occa`              | CUDA OCCA kernels                                   |
36068e843eeSJed Brown| `/omp/occa`              | OpenMP OCCA kernels                                 |
36168e843eeSJed Brown| `/ocl/occa`              | OpenCL OCCA kernels                                 |
36268e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/cuda/ref`          | Reference pure CUDA kernels                         |
36368e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/cuda/reg`          | Pure CUDA kernels using one thread per element      |
36468e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/magma`             | CUDA MAGMA kernels                                  |
365bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
366bcb2dfaeSJed BrownExamples available in this release:
367bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
36868e843eeSJed Brown:::{list-table}
36968e843eeSJed Brown:header-rows: 1
37068e843eeSJed Brown:widths: auto
37168e843eeSJed Brown* - User code
37268e843eeSJed Brown  - Example
37368e843eeSJed Brown* - `ceed`
37468e843eeSJed Brown  - * ex1 (volume)
37568e843eeSJed Brown* - `mfem`
37668e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
37768e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
37868e843eeSJed Brown* - `petsc`
37968e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
38068e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
38168e843eeSJed Brown    * Navier-Stokes
38268e843eeSJed Brown* - `nek5000`
38368e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
38468e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
38568e843eeSJed Brown:::
386bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
387bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-3)=
388bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
389bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.3 (Sep 30, 2018)
390bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
391bcb2dfaeSJed BrownNotable features in this release include active/passive field interface, support for
392bcb2dfaeSJed Brownnon-tensor bases, backend optimization, and improved Fortran interface. This release
393bcb2dfaeSJed Brownalso focused on providing improved continuous integration, and many new tests with code
394bcb2dfaeSJed Browncoverage reports of about 90%. This release also provided a significant change to the
395bcb2dfaeSJed Brownpublic interface: a {ref}`CeedQFunction` can take any number of named input and output
396bcb2dfaeSJed Brownarguments while {ref}`CeedOperator` connects them to the actual data, which may be
397bcb2dfaeSJed Brownsupplied explicitly to `CeedOperatorApply()` (active) or separately via
398bcb2dfaeSJed Brown`CeedOperatorSetField()` (passive). This interface change enables reusable libraries
399bcb2dfaeSJed Brownof CeedQFunctions and composition of block solvers constructed using
400bcb2dfaeSJed Brown{ref}`CeedOperator`. A concept of blocked restriction was added to this release and
401bcb2dfaeSJed Brownused in an optimized CPU backend. Although this is typically not visible to the user,
402bcb2dfaeSJed Brownit enables effective use of arbitrary-length SIMD while maintaining cache locality.
403bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThis CPU backend also implements an algebraic factorization of tensor product gradients
404bcb2dfaeSJed Brownto perform fewer operations than standard application of interpolation and
405bcb2dfaeSJed Browndifferentiation from nodes to quadrature points. This algebraic formulation
406bcb2dfaeSJed Brownautomatically supports non-polynomial and non-interpolatory bases, thus is more general
407bcb2dfaeSJed Brownthan the more common derivation in terms of Lagrange polynomials on the quadrature points.
408bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
409bcb2dfaeSJed BrownBackends available in this release:
410bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
41168e843eeSJed Brown| CEED resource (`-ceed`) | Backend                                             |
41268e843eeSJed Brown|-------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------|
41368e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/blocked`     | Blocked reference implementation                    |
41468e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/ref`         | Serial reference implementation                     |
41568e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self/tmpl`        | Backend template, defaults to `/cpu/self/blocked`   |
41668e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/occa`             | Serial OCCA kernels                                 |
41768e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/occa`             | CUDA OCCA kernels                                   |
41868e843eeSJed Brown| `/omp/occa`             | OpenMP OCCA kernels                                 |
41968e843eeSJed Brown| `/ocl/occa`             | OpenCL OCCA kernels                                 |
42068e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/magma`            | CUDA MAGMA kernels                                  |
421bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
422bcb2dfaeSJed BrownExamples available in this release:
423bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
42468e843eeSJed Brown:::{list-table}
42568e843eeSJed Brown:header-rows: 1
42668e843eeSJed Brown:widths: auto
42768e843eeSJed Brown* - User code
42868e843eeSJed Brown  - Example
42968e843eeSJed Brown* - `ceed`
43068e843eeSJed Brown  - * ex1 (volume)
43168e843eeSJed Brown* - `mfem`
43268e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
43368e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
43468e843eeSJed Brown* - `petsc`
43568e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
43668e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
43768e843eeSJed Brown* - `nek5000`
43868e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
43968e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
44068e843eeSJed Brown:::
441bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
442bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-21)=
443bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
444bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.21 (Sep 30, 2018)
445bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
446bcb2dfaeSJed BrownA MAGMA backend (which relies upon the
447bcb2dfaeSJed Brown[MAGMA](https://bitbucket.org/icl/magma) package) was integrated in libCEED for this
448bcb2dfaeSJed Brownrelease. This initial integration set up the framework of using MAGMA and provided the
449bcb2dfaeSJed BrownlibCEED functionality through MAGMA kernels as one of libCEED’s computational backends.
450bcb2dfaeSJed BrownAs any other backend, the MAGMA backend provides extended basic data structures for
451bcb2dfaeSJed Brown{ref}`CeedVector`, {ref}`CeedElemRestriction`, and {ref}`CeedOperator`, and implements
452bcb2dfaeSJed Brownthe fundamental CEED building blocks to work with the new data structures.
453bcb2dfaeSJed BrownIn general, the MAGMA-specific data structures keep the libCEED pointers to CPU data
454bcb2dfaeSJed Brownbut also add corresponding device (e.g., GPU) pointers to the data. Coherency is handled
455bcb2dfaeSJed Browninternally, and thus seamlessly to the user, through the functions/methods that are
456bcb2dfaeSJed Brownprovided to support them.
457bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
458bcb2dfaeSJed BrownBackends available in this release:
459bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
46068e843eeSJed Brown| CEED resource (`-ceed`) | Backend                         |
46168e843eeSJed Brown|-------------------------|---------------------------------|
46268e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self`             | Serial reference implementation |
46368e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/occa`             | Serial OCCA kernels             |
46468e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/occa`             | CUDA OCCA kernels               |
46568e843eeSJed Brown| `/omp/occa`             | OpenMP OCCA kernels             |
46668e843eeSJed Brown| `/ocl/occa`             | OpenCL OCCA kernels             |
46768e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/magma`            | CUDA MAGMA kernels              |
468bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
469bcb2dfaeSJed BrownExamples available in this release:
470bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
47168e843eeSJed Brown:::{list-table}
47268e843eeSJed Brown:header-rows: 1
47368e843eeSJed Brown:widths: auto
47468e843eeSJed Brown* - User code
47568e843eeSJed Brown  - Example
47668e843eeSJed Brown* - `ceed`
47768e843eeSJed Brown  - * ex1 (volume)
47868e843eeSJed Brown* - `mfem`
47968e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
48068e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
48168e843eeSJed Brown* - `petsc`
48268e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
48368e843eeSJed Brown* - `nek5000`
48468e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
48568e843eeSJed Brown:::
486bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
487bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-2)=
488bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
489bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.2 (Mar 30, 2018)
490bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
491bcb2dfaeSJed BrownlibCEED was made publicly available the first full CEED software distribution, release
492bcb2dfaeSJed BrownCEED 1.0. The distribution was made available using the Spack package manager to provide
493bcb2dfaeSJed Browna common, easy-to-use build environment, where the user can build the CEED distribution
494bcb2dfaeSJed Brownwith all dependencies. This release included a new Fortran interface for the library.
495bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThis release also contained major improvements in the OCCA backend (including a new
496bcb2dfaeSJed Brown`/ocl/occa` backend) and new examples. The standalone libCEED example was modified to
497bcb2dfaeSJed Browncompute the volume volume of a given mesh (in 1D, 2D, or 3D) and placed in an
498bcb2dfaeSJed Brown`examples/ceed` subfolder. A new `mfem` example to perform BP3 (with the application
499bcb2dfaeSJed Brownof the Laplace operator) was also added to this release.
500bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
501bcb2dfaeSJed BrownBackends available in this release:
502bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
50368e843eeSJed Brown| CEED resource (`-ceed`) | Backend                         |
50468e843eeSJed Brown|-------------------------|---------------------------------|
50568e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self`             | Serial reference implementation |
50668e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/occa`             | Serial OCCA kernels             |
50768e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/occa`             | CUDA OCCA kernels               |
50868e843eeSJed Brown| `/omp/occa`             | OpenMP OCCA kernels             |
50968e843eeSJed Brown| `/ocl/occa`             | OpenCL OCCA kernels             |
510bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
511bcb2dfaeSJed BrownExamples available in this release:
512bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
51368e843eeSJed Brown:::{list-table}
51468e843eeSJed Brown:header-rows: 1
51568e843eeSJed Brown:widths: auto
51668e843eeSJed Brown* - User code
51768e843eeSJed Brown  - Example
51868e843eeSJed Brown* - `ceed`
51968e843eeSJed Brown  - * ex1 (volume)
52068e843eeSJed Brown* - `mfem`
52168e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
52268e843eeSJed Brown    * BP3 (scalar Laplace operator)
52368e843eeSJed Brown* - `petsc`
52468e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
52568e843eeSJed Brown* - `nek5000`
52668e843eeSJed Brown  - * BP1 (scalar mass operator)
52768e843eeSJed Brown:::
528bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
529bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(v0-1)=
530bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
531bcb2dfaeSJed Brown## v0.1 (Jan 3, 2018)
532bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
533bcb2dfaeSJed BrownInitial low-level API of the CEED project. The low-level API provides a set of Finite
534bcb2dfaeSJed BrownElements kernels and components for writing new low-level kernels. Examples include:
535bcb2dfaeSJed Brownvector and sparse linear algebra, element matrix assembly over a batch of elements,
536bcb2dfaeSJed Brownpartial assembly and action for efficient high-order operators like mass, diffusion,
537bcb2dfaeSJed Brownadvection, etc. The main goal of the low-level API is to establish the basis for the
538bcb2dfaeSJed Brownhigh-level API. Also, identifying such low-level kernels and providing a reference
539bcb2dfaeSJed Brownimplementation for them serves as the basis for specialized backend implementations.
540bcb2dfaeSJed BrownThis release contained several backends: `/cpu/self`, and backends which rely upon the
541bcb2dfaeSJed Brown[OCCA](http://github.com/libocca/occa) package, such as `/cpu/occa`,
542bcb2dfaeSJed Brown`/gpu/occa`, and `/omp/occa`.
543bcb2dfaeSJed BrownIt also included several examples, in the `examples` folder:
544bcb2dfaeSJed BrownA standalone code that shows the usage of libCEED (with no external
545bcb2dfaeSJed Browndependencies) to apply the Laplace operator, `ex1`; an `mfem` example to perform BP1
546bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(with the application of the mass operator); and a `petsc` example to perform BP1
547bcb2dfaeSJed Brown(with the application of the mass operator).
548bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
549bcb2dfaeSJed BrownBackends available in this release:
550bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
55168e843eeSJed Brown| CEED resource (`-ceed`) | Backend                         |
55268e843eeSJed Brown|-------------------------|---------------------------------|
55368e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/self`             | Serial reference implementation |
55468e843eeSJed Brown| `/cpu/occa`             | Serial OCCA kernels             |
55568e843eeSJed Brown| `/gpu/occa`             | CUDA OCCA kernels               |
55668e843eeSJed Brown| `/omp/occa`             | OpenMP OCCA kernels             |
557bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
558bcb2dfaeSJed BrownExamples available in this release:
559bcb2dfaeSJed Brown
560bcb2dfaeSJed Brown| User code             | Example                           |
56168e843eeSJed Brown|-----------------------|-----------------------------------|
56268e843eeSJed Brown| `ceed`                | ex1 (scalar Laplace operator)     |
56368e843eeSJed Brown| `mfem`                | BP1 (scalar mass operator)        |
56468e843eeSJed Brown| `petsc`               | BP1 (scalar mass operator)        |
565bcb2dfaeSJed Brown```
566